Trevor Ing / Editor-In-Chief
At the beginning of every school year, teachers may retire, and teachers step up and take higher roles or new teachers are hired in replacement. The same goes for coaches of different sports.
This year, Stow saw the addition of five new sports coaches. Girls’ and boys’ basketball, girls’ soccer, baseball and bowling.
Recently, there has been a huge emphasis on high school sports. A student’s coach can quickly become the most important teacher they have, and when that teacher walks the hallways of their own school, it may mean more to the student than expected.
Many of these coaches have been at Stow for many years, so what brought about this change?
When figuring out the right person for the job, the Athletic Department first needs to figure out what exactly they want to have as a priority. Recently, the school has introduced a new emphasis on hiring coaches who are teachers at the school before reaching out to the community.
“We emphasize that if they’re walking the halls, we want to get them coaching,” Athletic Director, Cyle Feldman said.
With the coaching contract being one year, the athletic department had enough time to communicate and decide on teachers in the building who would be better suited to fit the needs of the student athletes. In Feldman’s mind, “you always are looking for what’s best for kids.”
A huge component of the change was that each coach needs to understand what’s happening in the classroom as well as on the field. For example, there was a problem with volleyball matches ending late, which caused many athletes to be unable to get all their work finished without sacrificing the much needed sleep to recover from a big game. A teacher in the building has better understanding and is able to communicate much better to other teachers if problems like this occur.
“If somebody’s walking our halls, we want them to be able to see our kids during the day and have an influence on them, mentoring them and communicating with them,” Feldman said.
One big coaching change that received a lot of attention was the replacement of Bob Podges, the previous girls’ basketball coach, who had been coaching for 32 years. Math teacher Andrew O’Keefe will be taking Podges’ position as the new girls head coach. O’Keefe has been coaching at CVCA for the past eight years. O’Keefe posted a 137-65 record in eight seasons as CVCA’s girls’ basketball coach, winning six league titles, three district championships and four Coach of the Year honors.
Similar to O’Keefe, Podges coached 12 league Players of the Year, named Ohio High School Basketball Coaches Association Division I Coach of the Year back in 2017, earned league Coach of the Year 12 times and was named the All-Ohio Northeast Inland District Division 1 Coach of the Year three times.
Continued on website…
So this begs the question, why not continue the contract of a coach who has such an incredible legacy?
According to Feldman, it came down to two things. The first being the emphasis on having a coach be one of the administrators in the school to better mentor their athletes, and the second being how much of a relationship O’Keefe was building with the younger generation.
“One of our big goals in all our programs is aligning with the youth, and Kimpton, and the early returns on coach O’Keefe are great,” Feldman said.
A big problem with basketball, along with other sports at Stow, is how many students are advancing CVCA or Walsh instead of the Stow because of athletics. One of the reasons students were going to CVCA instead of Stow was because they knew about O’Keefe prior to going to high school.
While coaching at CVCA, O’Keefe felt a disconnect between himself and the community at Stow. At the time, both head coach positions were taken at Stow, so O’Keefe didn’t see a path where he would become the head coach while working under Coach Dave Close. He was given the opportunity to become a Head Coach at CVCA and took it despite it not being his home school.
“I remember my first pep rally after getting hired at CVCA, and I just stood there in the gym, and I was just like, ‘man.’ It just wasn’t the same for me. It was hard because I wasn’t coaching here anymore,” O’Keefe said.
O’Keefe also felt how much he lost with not having his athletes in his classroom. He felt like a huge part of how he coaches was gone because he lost that ability to connect.
“I lost that relationship that gets developed in the gym. I think it’s completely different than the classroom because in the classroom, kids are working on something that they have to do; whereas in the gym, they’re working on something that they love,” O’Keefe said.
When administrators gave O’Keefe the opportunity to become the new girls’ head coach, he stepped up for the job hoping to follow Podges’ legacy the best he could.
“They saw me as a qualified candidate, and they asked me if I’d be interested in applying for the position, and I did,” O’Keefe said.
Besides the controversy, O’Keefe is excited for this year and thinks the team will perform well. O’Keefe was not just handed the job solely because he was a teacher who applied.
“I’m really excited to be back. I think the girls are excited, I think families are excited, and we’re looking forward to the season,” O’Keefe said.

Source: Stohion/ Maya Cooper
Girls basketball coach Andrew O’Keefe coaches the 11/15 scrimmage.